

STATISTICAL PAGES 

Year : 2015  Volume
: 1
 Issue : 1  Page : 6971 

Chisquare test and its application in hypothesis testing
Rakesh Rana, Richa Singhal
Statistical Section, Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences, Ministry of AYUSH, GOI, New Delhi, India
Date of Web Publication  22May2015 
Correspondence Address: Dr. Richa Singhal Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences, Ministry of AYUSH, GOI, New Delhi India
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None  Check 
DOI: 10.4103/23955414.157577
In medical research, there are studies which often collect data on categorical variables that can be summarized as a series of counts. These counts are commonly arranged in a tabular format known as a contingency table. The chisquare test statistic can be used to evaluate whether there is an association between the rows and columns in a contingency table. More specifically, this statistic can be used to determine whether there is any difference between the study groups in the proportions of the risk factor of interest. Chisquare test and the logic of hypothesis testing were developed by Karl Pearson. This article describes in detail what is a chisquare test, on which type of data it is used, the assumptions associated with its application, how to manually calculate it and how to make use of an online calculator for calculating the Chisquare statistics and its associated Pvalue. Keywords: Categorical data analysis, Chisquare test, hypothesis testing, online calculator
How to cite this article: Rana R, Singhal R. Chisquare test and its application in hypothesis testing. J Pract Cardiovasc Sci 2015;1:6971 
The logic of hypothesis testing was first invented by Karl Pearson (18571936), a renaissance scientist, in Victorian London in 1900. ^{[1]} Pearson's Chisquare distribution and the Chisquare test also known as test for goodnessoffit and test of independence are his most important contribution to the modern theory of statistics. The importance of Pearson's Chisquare distribution was that, the statisticians could use the statistical methods that did not depend on the normal distribution to interpret the findings. He invented the Chisquare distribution to mainly cater the needs of biologists, economists, and psychologists. His paper in 1900 published in Philosophical magazine elaborates the invention of Chisquare distribution and goodness of fit test. ^{[2],[3]}
Chisquare test is a nonparametric test used for two specific purpose: (a) To test the hypothesis of no association between two or more groups, population or criteria (i.e. to check independence between two variables); (b) and to test how likely the observed distribution of data fits with the distribution that is expected (i.e., to test the goodnessoffit). It is used to analyze categorical data (e.g. male or female patients, smokers and nonsmokers, etc.), it is not meant to analyze parametric or continuous data (e.g., height measured in centimeters or weight measured in kg, etc.).
For example if we want to test that in a health camp attended by 50 persons the one who exercise regularly are having lesser body mass index (BMI) by taking their actual BMI values, than it cannot be tested using a Chisquare test. However, if we divide the same set of 50 persons into two categories as obese with BMI ≥ 30 and nonobese with BMI < 30, than the same data can be tested using a Chisquare test by counting the number of obese and nonobese persons across two groups, the one who exercise regularly and the one who does not. A 2x2 contingency table also known as cross tables can be constructed for calculating a Chisquare statistic [Table 1].
Assumptions Underlying a Chisquare Test   
 The data are randomly drawn from a population
 The values in the cells are considered adequate when expected counts are not <5 and there are no cells with zero count ^{[4],[5]}
 The sample size is sufficiently large. The application of the Chisquare test to a smaller sample could lead to type II error (i.e. accepting the null hypothesis when it is actually false). There is no expected cutoff for the sample size; however, the minimum sample size varies from 20 to 50
 The variables under consideration must be mutually exclusive. It means that each variable must only be counted once in a particular category and should not be allowed to appear in other category. In other, words no item shall be counted twice.
How to Calculate a Chisquare Statistics?   
The formula for calculating a Chisquare statistic is:
Where,
O stands for the observed frequency,
E stands for the expected frequency.
Expected count is subtracted from the observed count to find the difference between the two. Then the square of the difference is calculated to get rid of the negative vales (as the squares of 2 and −2 are, of course, both 4). Then the square of the difference is divided by the expected count to normalize bigger and smaller values (because we don't want to get bigger Chisquare values just because we are working on large data sets). The sigma sign in front of them denotes that we have, to sum up, these values calculated for each cell.
As an example, suppose we want to find out that whether there is an association between smoking and lung disease.
The null and alternative hypothesis will be:
H _{0} : There is no association between smoking and lung disease.
H _{1} : There is an association between smoking and lung disease.
The basic step for calculating a Chisquare test is setting up a 2 × 2 contingency table [Table 2].  Table 2: General notation for a 2×2 contingency table (observed values for the data)
Click here to view 
The general formula for calculating the expected counts from observed count for a particular cell is [(corresponding row total * corresponding column total) /Total no. of patients] [Table 3].
Before we proceed further, we need to know how many degrees of freedom (df) we have. When a comparison is made between one sample and another, a simple rule is that the df equals (number of columns − 1) × (number of rows − 1) excluding the rows and column containing the total. Hence, in our example df = (2−1) × (2−1) = 1.
Hypothetical data for calculating the Chisquare test for our example of testing an association between smoking and lung disease is given in [Table 4]. Chisquare test can be calculated manually by using the formula described above. Refer [Table 5] and [Table 6] for manual calculations. Chisquare value for our example as shown in [Table 6] is 3.42, df = 1. If we want to test our hypothesis at 5% level of significance than our predetermined alpha level of significance is 0.05. Looking into the Chisquare distribution table [Table 7] with 1 degree of freedom and reading along the row we find our value of χ^{2} (3.42) lies between 2.706 and 3.841. The corresponding probability is between the 0.10 and 0.05 probability levels. That means that the P value is above 0.05 (it is actually 0.065). Since a P value of 0.065 is greater than the conventionally accepted significance level of 0.05 (i.e., P > 0.05) we fail to reject the null hypothesis or in other words we accept our null hypothesis and conclude that there is no association between smoking and lung disease.  Table 4: Hypothetical data containing observed values for calculating Chisquare statistics
Click here to view 
How to Use a Chisquare Distribution Table to Approximate P Value?   
Scientists and statisticians use large tables of values to calculate the P value for their experiment. These tables are generally set up with the vertical axis on the left corresponding to df and the horizontal axis on the top corresponding to P value. Use these tables by first finding our df, then reading that row across from the left to the right until we find the first value bigger than our Chisquare value. Look at the corresponding P value at the top of the column. Chisquare distribution tables are available from a variety of sourcesthey can easily be found online or in science and statistics textbooks.
Using an Online Chisquare Calculator   
The Chisquare statistics and its associated P value can be calculated through online calculators also which are easily available on the internet. For userfriendly online calculator, you may visit this uniform resource locator www.socscistatistics.com/tests/chisquare/default2.aspx. Many more online calculators are available on the World Wide Web. The basic step for using an online calculator is to correctly fill in your data into it.
Step by step procedure of using an online calculator is described below:
 Step 1: For our example of finding an association between smoking and lung disease we have to fill in the observed values in the cells of an online calculator [Figure 1]
 Figure 1: Setting up the data in the 2 × 2 table of an online calculator.
Click here to view 
 Step 2: Click on the next button. Another screen will pop up as shown in [Figure 2]
 Step 3: Click on the Calculate Chi^2 button. And you are done with your calculation Output of the Chisquare test will be as shown in [Figure 3].
The image above shows the Chisquare value as 3.4177 and its associated P value as 0.0645 which is actually greater than P value of 0.05, hence no significant difference has been observed. To conclude, there is no association between smoking and lung disease.
What Does a Chisquare Test Tell and What it Does Not?   
It may be clearly understood that Chisquare test only tells us the probability of independence of a distribution of data or in simple terms it will only test that whether two variables are associated with each other or not. It will not tell us that how closely they are associated. For instance in the above example, the Chisquare test will only tell us that whether there is any relation between smoking and lung disease. It will not tell us that how likely it is, that smokers are prone to lung disease. However, once we got to know that there is a relation between these two variables, we can explore other methods to calculate the amount of association between them.
References   
1.  Magnello ME Karl Pearson and the origin of modern statistics: An elastician becomes a statistician, Rutherford J, Vol. 1, 20052006. Available online at: http://rutherfordjournal.org. 
2.  Pearson K. On the criterion that a given system of deviations from the probable in the case of a correlated system of variables is such that it can be reasonably supposed to have arisen from random sampling. Philos Mag Ser 1900;50:15775. 
3.  Plackett RL. Karl Pearson and the Chisquared test. Int Stat Rev 1983;51:5972. 
4.  Yates F, Moore D, McCabe G. The Practice of Statistics 1 ^{st} ed. New York: W.H.Freeman, 1999. 
5.  Yates F. Contingency table involving small numbers and the Chisquared test. Suppl J R Stat Soc 1934;1:21735. 
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6], [Table 7]
This article has been cited by  1 
Visual placebolike effects on subjective assessment of room acoustics: Sound absorption in classrooms 

 M. Caniato, Nicolò Biasetton, Luigi Salmaso, Andrea Gasparella   Building and Environment. 2022; : 109647   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   2 
Indian government initiatives on cyberbullying: A case study on cyberbullying in Indian higher education institutions 

 Manpreet Kaur, Munish Saini   Education and Information Technologies. 2022;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   3 
Bioenergetic and vascular predictors of potential superager and cognitive decline trajectories—a UK Biobank Random Forest classification study 

 Parvin Mohammadiarvejeh, Brandon S. Klinedinst, Qian Wang, Tianqi Li, Brittany Larsen, Amy Pollpeter, Shannin N. Moody, Sara A. Willette, Jon P. Mochel, Karin Allenspach, Guiping Hu, Auriel A. Willette   GeroScience. 2022;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   4 
Developing design guidelines for university campus in hot climate using Quality Function Deployment (QFD): the case of the University of Sharjah, UAE 

 Emad Mushtaha, Imad Alsyouf, Rawan Hamad, Abbas Elmualim, Aref Maksoud, Moohammed Wasim Yahia   Architectural Engineering and Design Management. 2022; : 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   5 
Machine learning algorithms as new screening approach for patients with endometriosis 

 Sofiane Bendifallah, Anne Puchar, Stéphane Suisse, Léa Delbos, Mathieu Poilblanc, Philippe Descamps, Francois Golfier, Cyril Touboul, Yohann Dabi, Emile Daraï   Scientific Reports. 2022; 12(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   6 
A machine learning analysis of COVID19 mental health data 

 Mostafa Rezapour, Lucas Hansen   Scientific Reports. 2022; 12(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   7 
Improved Poverty Tracking and Targeting in Jordan Using Feature Selection and Machine Learning 

 Adham Alsharkawi, Mohammad AlFetyani, Maha Dawas, Heba Saadeh, Musa Alyaman   IEEE Access. 2022; 10: 86483   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   8 
Driver Identification Using Optimized Deep Learning Model in Smart Transportation 

 Chandrasekar Ravi, Anmol Tigga, G Thippa Reddy, Saqib Hakak, Mamoun Alazab   ACM Transactions on Internet Technology. 2022;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   9 
COVID19 Risk Stratification and Mortality Prediction in Hospitalized Indian Patients: Harnessing clinical data for public health benefits 

 Shanmukh Alle, Akshay Kanakan, Samreen Siddiqui, Akshit Garg, Akshaya Karthikeyan, Priyanka Mehta, Neha Mishra, Partha Chattopadhyay, Priti Devi, Swati Waghdhare, Akansha Tyagi, Bansidhar Tarai, Pranjal Pratim Hazarik, Poonam Das, Sandeep Budhiraja, Vivek Nangia, Arun Dewan, Ramanathan Sethuraman, C. Subramanian, Mashrin Srivastava, Avinash Chakravarthi, Johnny Jacob, Madhuri Namagiri, Varma Konala, Debasish Dash, Tavpritesh Sethi, Sujeet Jha, Anurag Agrawal, Rajesh Pandey, P. K. Vinod, U. Deva Priyakumar, Binh P. Nguyen   PLOS ONE. 2022; 17(3): e0264785   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   10 
Socioeconomic inequality in the prevalence of low birth weight and its associated determinants in Bangladesh 

 Md. Jahangir Alam, Md. Merajul Islam, Md. Maniruzzaman, N. A. M. Faisal Ahmed, Most. Tawabunnahar, Md. Jahanur Rahman, Dulal Chandra Roy, Janardhan Mydam, Dayana Farias   PLOS ONE. 2022; 17(10): e0276718   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   11 
A study of learners’ interactive preference on multimedia microlearning 

 Anna Sung, Kelvin Leong, Ching Lee   Journal of WorkApplied Management. 2022;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   12 
A Comprehensive Analysis of Chinese, Japanese, Korean, USPIMA Indian, and Trinidadian Screening Scores for Diabetes Risk Assessment and Prediction 

 Norma Latif Fitriyani, Muhammad Syafrudin, Siti Maghfirotul Ulyah, Ganjar Alfian, Syifa Latif Qolbiyani, Muhammad Anshari   Mathematics. 2022; 10(21): 4027   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   13 
A LowCost MultiSensor Data Acquisition System for Fault Detection in Fused Deposition Modelling 

 Satish Kumar, Tushar Kolekar, Shruti Patil, Arunkumar Bongale, Ketan Kotecha, Atef Zaguia, Chander Prakash   Sensors. 2022; 22(2): 517   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   14 
Modeling of Food Consumption Behavior in the Quarantine Period Applied during the Coronavirus SARSCoV2 (COVID19) Outbreak in Turkey 

 Asli Zulug, Dilay Merve Temur, Sevda Kaya, Müge Ertem   Sustainability. 2022; 14(4): 1975   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   15 
An Integrated Online/Offline Social NetworkBased Model for Crowdfunding Support in Developing Countries: The Case of Nigeria 

 Kanayo Ogwu, Patrick Hickey, Okeoma JohnPaul Okeke, Adnan ul Haque, Elias Pimenidis, Eugene Kozlovski   Sustainability. 2022; 14(15): 9333   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   16 
The Need for a Proper Waste Management Plan for the Construction Industry: A Case Study in Lebanon 

 Ali Saad, Menoka Bal, Jamal Khatib   Sustainability. 2022; 14(19): 12783   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   17 
The Effect of NonPrice Policies on Household Tobacco Consumption Among the Filipino Youth in City of Manila 

 Jillianne O. Marcelino, Thea Janelle D. Waje, Ronaldo R. Cabauatan   Millennium Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences. 2022; : 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   18 
An Analysis into the Contribution of Google Applications in the Successful Implementation of Online Education During the COVID19 Pandemic 

 Rajeshwari M.,Rajeshwari Vinayachandra,Geetha Poornima K.,Krishna Prasad K.   International Journal of Applied Engineering and Management Letters. 2021; : 131   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   19 
The Effect of Integration of Different Online Education Methods on Educational Advancement and Student Development: A Study 

 Geetha Poornima K.,Geetha Poornima Vinayachandra,Rajeshwari M.,Krishna Prasad K.   International Journal of Case Studies in Business, IT, and Education. 2021; : 200   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   20 
Students’ Perception of the Effectiveness of Technology Assisted Online Education During COVID19 Pandemic: An Empirical Study 

 Michal Vinayachandra,Geetha Poornima K.,Rajeshwari M.,Krishna Prasad K.   International Journal of Management, Technology, and Social Sciences. 2021; : 203   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   21 
The Prevalence of Potentially Inappropriate Prescribing in the Elderly at the Primary Care Level in Kazakhstan 

 Ainash Ibysheva,Gulmira Muldaeva,Leila I. Arystan,Almagul B. Kuzgibekova,Bibigul A. Abeuova,Leila S. Haydargalieva   Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences. 2021; 9(A): 572   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   22 
The impact of COVID19 outbreak and perceptions of people towards household waste management chain in Nepal 

 Ashis Acharya,Govinda Bastola,Bindu Modi,Asmi Marhatta,Suraj Belbase,Ganesh Lamichhane,Narayan Gyawali,Ranjan Kumar Dahal   Geoenvironmental Disasters. 2021; 8(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   23 
Predicting Increase in Demand for Public Buses in University Students Daily Life Needs: Case Study Based on a City in Japan 

 Ali Bakdur,Fumito Masui,Michal Ptaszynski   Sustainability. 2021; 13(9): 5137   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   24 
Impact of Gender and Expatriation Choice on Career Paths in Supply Chain Management: Evidence from Master of Science Graduates 

 Salomée Ruel,Anicia Jaegler   Sustainability. 2021; 13(12): 6907   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   25 
Towards Sustainable Private Labels in an Autonomous Community during COVID19—Analysis of Consumer Behavior and Perception on the Example of Tenerife 

 Maksymilian Czeczotko,Hanna GórskaWarsewicz,Waclaw Laskowski,Barbara Rostecka   Sustainability. 2021; 13(13): 7467   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   26 
HARP 

 Yashen Wang,Huanhuan Zhang   ACM Transactions on Knowledge Discovery from Data. 2021; 15(2): 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   27 
Spatial modeling of radon potential mapping using deep learning algorithms 

 Mahdi Panahi, Peyman Yariyan, Fatemeh Rezaie, Sung Won Kim, Alireza Sharifi, Ali Asghar Alesheikh, Jongchun Lee, Jungsub Lee, Seonhong Kim, Juhee Yoo, Saro Lee   Geocarto International. 2021; : 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   28 
Patients 80?+ have similar medication initiation rates to those aged 50–79 in Ontario FLS 

 J. E. M. Sale,A. Yang,V. ElliotGibson,R. Jain,R. Sujic,D. Linton,J. Weldon,L. Frankel,E. Bogoch   Osteoporosis International. 2021;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   29 
Investigating the prevalence and predictors of food insecurity: a comparison of HFSSM and EUSILC indicators 

 Emma Beacom, Christopher McLaughlin, Sinéad Furey, Lynsey Elizabeth Hollywood, Paul Humphreys   British Food Journal. 2021; aheadofp(aheadofp)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   30 
Preference between Indian Picture Symbols for Communication (IPSC) and Picture Communication Symbols (PCS) in neurotypical adults and adults with aphasia 

 Vineetha Sara Philip,S. P. Goswami   Speech, Language and Hearing. 2021; : 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   31 
Repurposing new drug candidates and identifying crucial molecules underlying PCOS Pathogenesis Based On Bioinformatics Analysis 

 Zeinab Dehghan,Samira MohammadiYeganeh,Marzieh Sameni,Seyed Amir Mirmotalebisohi,Hakimeh Zali,Mohammad Salehi   DARU Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences. 2021;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   32 
Development of a conceptual framework for risk assessment of elevated internal temperatures in landfills 

 Samain Sabrin,Rouzbeh Nazari,Maryam Karimi,Md Golam Rabbani Fahad,Jess Everett,Robert Peters   Science of The Total Environment. 2021; 782: 146831   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   33 
Soillitter ant (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) community response to reforested lands of Gishwati tropical montane forest, northernwestern part of Rwanda 

 Venuste Nsengimana,Wouter Dekoninck   Journal of Tropical Ecology. 2021; : 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   34 
Machine learning predicts livebirth occurrence before invitro fertilization treatment 

 Ashish Goyal,Maheshwar Kuchana,Kameswari Prasada Rao Ayyagari   Scientific Reports. 2020; 10(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   35 
Customers perception on logistics service quality using Kansei engineering: empirical evidence from indonesian logistics providers 

 Dian Palupi Restuputri,Ilyas Masudin,Citra Permata Sari,Albert W. K. Tan   Cogent Business & Management. 2020; 7(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   36 
Over 40% of 450 registered wheat cultivars (Triticum aestivum) worldwide are composed of multiple biotypes 

 Eugene Metakovsky,Viktor Melnik,Laura Pascual,Colin W. Wrigley   Journal of Cereal Science. 2020; : 103088   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   37 
Analyzing expectation of landowners from Brownfield TOD project: A case study from MP Nagar, Bhopal 

 Manmeet C. Verma,Rahul Tiwari   Materials Today: Proceedings. 2020;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   38 
Test of Association in the Presence of Complex Environment 

 Muhammad Aslam,Osama H. Arif   Complexity. 2020; 2020: 1   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   39 
Understanding Discharge Voltage Inconsistency in LithiumIon Cells via Statistical Characteristics and Numerical Analysis 

 Linshu Wang,Yanyan Fang,Lve Wang,Fengling Yun,Jiantao Wang,Shigang Lu   IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 84821   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   40 
Machine LearningBased Application for Predicting Risk of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) in Saudi Arabia: A Retrospective CrossSectional Study 

 Asif Hassan Syed,Tabrej Khan   IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 199539   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   41 
Sustainability Balanced Scorecard Architecture and Environmental Investment DecisionMaking 

 Suaad Jassem,Zarina Zakaria,Anna Che Azmi   Foundations of Management. 2020; 12(1): 193   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   42 
Awareness level on the role of forensic DNA database in criminal investigation in Nigeria: A case study of Benin city 

 Udogadi Nwawuba Stanley, Blessing Nkiruka Akpata Chinyere   Journal of Forensic Science and Research. 2020; 4(1): 007   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   43 
A Novel RiskBased Prioritization Approach for Wireless Sensor Network Deployment in Pipeline Networks 

 Xiaojian Yi,Peng Hou,Haiping Dong   Energies. 2020; 13(6): 1512   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   44 
Fishers’ Perceptions and Attitudes toward Weather and Climate Information Services for Climate Change Adaptation in Senegal 

 Ndèye Seynabou Diouf,Issa Ouedraogo,Robert B. Zougmoré,Madické Niang   Sustainability. 2020; 12(22): 9465   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   45 
Embracing Sustainability in Shipping: Assessing Industry’s Adaptations Incited by the, Newly, Introduced ‘triple bottom line’ Approach to Sustainable Maritime Development 

 C.W. Fasoulis,C.W. Rafet   Social Sciences. 2019; 8(7): 208   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   46 
Gliadin genotypes worldwide for spring wheats (Triticum aestivum L.) 1. Genetic diversity and grainquality gliadin alleles during the 20th century 

 E. Metakovsky,V.A. Melnik,L. Pascual,C.W. Wrigley   Journal of Cereal Science. 2019; 87: 172   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   47 
Gliadin genotypes worldwide for spring wheats (Triticum aestivum L.) 2. Strong differentiation of polymorphism between countries and regions of origin 

 E. Metakovsky,V.A. Melnik,L. Pascual,C.W. Wrigley   Journal of Cereal Science. 2019; 87: 311   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   48 
Types, frequencies and value of intravarietal genotypic nonuniformity in common wheat cultivars: Authentic biotypes and foreign seeds 

 Eugene Metakovsky,Viktor Melnik,Laura Pascual,Georgy A. Romanov,Colin W. Wrigley   Journal of Cereal Science. 2019; : 102813   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   49 
There is a direct link between allantoin concentration and cadmium tolerance in Arabidopsis 

 Maryam Nourimand,Christopher D. Todd   Plant Physiology and Biochemistry. 2018;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   50 
Radiographer mammographersæ attitudes towards implementing new techniques for imaging the augmented breast, after viewing a training DVD or receiving cascade training: A survey 

 N.C. Moneme,J. Curtis   Radiography. 2018;   [Pubmed]  [DOI]   51 
Exploring student learning profiles in algebrabased studio physics: A personcentered approach 

 Jarrad W.?T. Pond,Jacquelyn J. Chini   Physical Review Physics Education Research. 2017; 13(1)   [Pubmed]  [DOI]  



